Okay, so I spent the whole weekend diving deep into Madden 24, trying to figure out who the best running backs are. Here’s the thing, it’s not just about the overall rating, you gotta look at the whole picture.
First off, I started by checking out the official ratings, you know, the ones that everyone talks about. Nick Chubb is at the top with a 97, and that makes sense, the dude’s a beast. But, I wanted to see if the ratings really matched up with how they play in the game.

So, I set up some exhibition matches, played through a few seasons, and really focused on how these guys move on the field. I paid attention to their speed, agility, how well they break tackles, all that stuff. Saquon Barkley, for example, has some killer stats. 93 Speed, 93 Acceleration, and 95 Agility, 96 Carrying. This guy can definitely make some big plays happen. He feels so quick and responsive when you control him. I managed to get some really nice runs with him, weaving through defenders and breaking tackles like it was nothing. It’s impressive.
But here’s the kicker: I found that some of the lower-rated RBs actually performed really well, maybe even better in certain situations. It really depends on your play style. For example, if you like to use a power run game, a guy with high trucking might be more valuable to you than someone with just high speed. Like, one time, I was using this RB with a high truck rating, and I just plowed through the defense, gaining an extra 5-6 yards after contact. It was insane!
And then, there are these X-factor abilities. “Freight Train” is just nuts. It’s seriously one of the best X-factors in the whole game. I experimented with it, and it’s crazy how often it activates. Literally, every time I ran the ball, it lit up. It gives you such a huge advantage, especially in crucial moments, helping you break tackles and make big plays.
After a ton of games and trying out different playbooks, I started to get a good feel for which RBs really shine. I also experimented with different offensive schemes to see how that affected their performance. For instance, I tried using a zone run scheme with a back who had high agility and vision, and it was a perfect match. He found the holes in the defense so easily, and I was getting consistent 5-10 yard gains every play. It was so satisfying to see!
Conclusion
-
Don’t just look at the overall rating. Dig into the individual stats and see how they fit your play style.
-
Experiment with different RBs, even the lower-rated ones. You might be surprised.
-
Pay attention to X-factors. “Freight Train” is a game-changer.
Ultimately, I think finding the best RB in Madden 24 is all about experimentation and finding what works best for you. I had a blast trying out all these different players and strategies, and I hope my experience helps you up your game too. Keep grinding, and you’ll find the perfect RB for your team!