Now, listen up, if you’re playin’ that game, MLB The Show 23, and you’re wonderin’ how to challenge a play, well, let me tell ya, it ain’t too hard once ya get the hang of it. I’m sure you’ve seen those real-life games where the manager trots out there to argue with the umpire, right? Well, in the game, you can do something similar, and I’m here to tell ya how.
Step 1: Get to the Right Mode

First things first, you gotta be in the right mode. In MLB The Show 23, you wanna go to the Custom Mode. You find that by scrollin’ through the menus until you hit on something called Creation Camp. That’s where you’ll be able to make all sorts of decisions, including challengin’ calls on the field.
Step 2: The Manager’s Challenge
Now, if ya wanna challenge a call, it’s like this: In the game, the manager gotta step up, just like in the real world. If you’re playin’ with a friend, you gotta go ahead and call the challenge from the dugout or walk out onto the field and tell the umpire you’re gonna challenge a call. If ya ever seen it done in real games, this is basically the same thing, just with a controller in your hand.
Step 3: Initiating the Challenge
Once you’ve got your mind set on challengin’, hit the button that’ll let ya do it. If you’re on a console, it’s usually a specific button that’ll bring up the option to challenge. It’ll be there on the screen when you need it. You don’t gotta worry about missin’ it, the game gives you all sorts of chances to make the call.
Step 4: Why You Might Want to Challenge
Now, you might be askin’ yourself, why challenge a play? Well, sometimes them umpires, or the game’s system, might not get things right. Maybe you think the player was safe or the ball was foul, but the ump said otherwise. That’s when you want to step in and say, “I’m gonna challenge that.”
Challenging a play can turn the tide of the game, especially if you’re playin’ against a tough CPU or a friend who’s givin’ you a run for your money. Just like in real baseball, a successful challenge could change the whole game. You get another chance, you know? If you don’t like the call, take the opportunity to make it right!
Step 5: The Challenge of the Week
Oh, and let me tell ya, every week, there’s something called the Challenge of the Week in MLB The Show 23. It’s not just about challengin’ calls, no, no. It’s a whole different thing. You gotta face off against a pitcher who gets tougher and tougher as you go. The more points you score, the better rewards you get. It’s like a game within the game!

Step 6: Practice Makes Perfect
Don’t think you’re gonna get it right every time, though. Nah, it takes a little practice. If you’re new to the game, it might take a few tries before you figure out the best way to use your challenges. But don’t worry, you’ll get the hang of it, just like ridin’ a bike. It’ll come to ya, and then you’ll be challengin’ calls like a pro!
Conclusion
So there ya have it. Challengin’ a play in MLB The Show 23 is as easy as pie once you know what you’re doin’. Just get into the right mode, call for that challenge, and see if you can get the ump to change his mind. It might not always work, but when it does, it’s mighty sweet. And don’t forget, there’s plenty of other challenges in the game, like that Challenge of the Week, where you can really test your skills. Good luck, and go challenge those plays!
Tags:[MLB The Show 23, challenge, manager’s challenge, Creation Camp, challenge of the week, gaming tips]