Okay, so I’ve been grinding away at MLB The Show lately, and one thing that’s been bugging me is figuring out the quick sell values for cards. It’s not always obvious, and sometimes you just want to get rid of a bunch of cards fast without having to list them all individually on the marketplace.
So, I started digging around to get to the bottom of this. First, I launched the game and jumped into Diamond Dynasty because that’s where all the card action happens. I wanted to see what the deal was with quick sell values.

After poking around the menus, I headed over to my card collection. I had a bunch of duplicates and low-value cards that I didn’t need. I started selecting cards one by one, and I noticed a “quick sell” option. That’s what I was looking for!
But here’s the thing – the quick sell values weren’t consistent. Some cards were worth more than others, even if they were the same type. It seemed like it depended on the player’s overall rating and maybe some other hidden factors.
- Common cards – These are pretty much worthless. You’re only gonna get like 5 stubs for them.
- Bronze cards – These can fetch you around 25-50 stubs, it really depends on the card itself.
- Silver cards – Now we’re talking. These are worth a bit more, usually somewhere between 100-200 stubs.
- Gold cards – These are where you can start to get some decent stubs. The range is pretty wide, but I saw anywhere from 500 to 1000 stubs.
- Diamond cards – Okay, if you’re quick selling a diamond, you better have a good reason! These can be worth several thousand stubs, sometimes even over 5000!
Here’s what I found out after experimenting with a few different cards:
So, I spent a good chunk of time going through my collection and quick-selling the cards I didn’t need. It was a bit tedious, but I ended up making a decent amount of stubs. I used those stubs to buy some new packs, hoping to pull a high-value card that I could either keep or sell for a big profit on the marketplace.
In the end, I realized that quick sell is a convenient way to get rid of unwanted cards and make some quick stubs, but it’s not always the best way to maximize your return. If you have the time and patience, listing cards individually on the marketplace can often get you a better price. But if you’re in a hurry or just want to clear out your collection, quick sell is definitely the way to go.
That’s my experience with quick sell values in MLB The Show. It was a bit of a learning process, but I think I’ve got a pretty good handle on it now. Hopefully, this helps some of you out there who are also trying to figure this stuff out!